Participatory Practices: A collective close reading


“Grew me up Green”, Mindy by Vahri McKenzie

The following is a poetic edit taken from an hour long Zoom Chat regarding a performance art piece, Colour me, Beautiful, as part of the Bunbury Biennale 2021, HE | SHE | THEY.  We were provoked by the idea of participatory as a feminist practice. Participatory is more than interactive. As a method, it is intentional, planned, and full of techniques. The Zoom Chat is participatory and responsive. As a feminist participatory practice, Zoom Chatting requires introductions, engagement, a willingness to respond in ways that are not just scholarly, invitations that open-up and make room for thinking, and thanks. It is a feminist practice, and is an example of how to do a collective close reading.

09:02:58             Hi I’m  ,from ECU on Whadjuk Noongar boodja.
09:03:08                 Welcome everyone.
09:03:08                     Kaurna land.
09:03:16                             on Whadjuck Nyungar boodja
09:03:26 I am joining        from Whadjuk Noongar boodja
09:03:26 I am on Whadjuk Noongar country in what is now known as Western Australia.
09:03:30 in Busselton WA
09:03:33 I’m distributed between Ngunnawal and Wardandi Country …
09:03:36 North Vancouver Canada!
09:03:37 I am zooming  tonight from the traditional, unceded territories of the Algonquin Nation.
09:03:38         Canada
09:03:39 Whadjuk Noongar boodja, south perth
09:03:49 on Beeloo Noongar boodja today
09:03:55 joining from Ottawa Canada
09:04:00 South England UK
09:04:01 Borloo, Whadjuk Noongar Boodja
09:04:10 on Ngunnawal country, in the ACT.
09:04:15 South of England UK
09:04:15 Melbourne on the Wurundjeri
09:04:22 Joondalup.
09:05:03 zooming   from     Whadjuk Noongar boodjar
09:05:08 Whadjuk Nyoongar Boodja.
09:05:16        Canada
09:06:46 Colour full of smell and touch
09:08:41        “Grew me up green”
09:09:42 Green is the colour of revolution for some people.
09:10:08 difficulty of choosing just one colour-one thing
09:10:08   and some people were banned wearing it!
09:10:32 Eucalyptus green Jarrah, Red Gum the smell and touch.
09:11:04 colour is a language in itself hence the difficulty in reducing it to words
09:11:36 those greens have lots of connotations!
09:15:28 reminds me of experimenting with colour & children. I worked with a group of 4 year olds who created their own colour that they named, 'owned' and shared. Their parents were invited to do the same.
09:15:48 the disruptions that working with artists bring to research-creation
09:16:07 Trace of every conversation...
09:16:13    I love artists and researchers being in responsive conversation with each other - it adds a rich and unique element to the notion of what is possible, what new spaces can be opened.
09:16:19 I love that she is painting free hand. Detail is beautiful
09:17:28 colour as conversation - remnants        pallet and brush. Frame the encounter as a portrait.
09:18:59  process, technique, and method
09:19:18      Belongs to a tradition of feminist performance art.
09:19:40       conceptual idea, not material object - process.
09:19:57                  challenging the ideas of materiality
09:20:07                    distributed authorship
09:20:16                 What techniques inform: set ups,
09:20:21 collaboration, co-created, distributed authorship
09:20:38  Vahri’s technique: Delegated, distributed and durational
09:21:35                    What it means to be prepared. Reclaiming delegation as a term of                                                                               distributed authorship
09:22:26   how explicit do conversations around gender need to be?
09:22:46     Katherine Molines work on co-creation
09:22:56                 Not expected to ‘represent’ gender
09:23:43                 colour stories 
09:24:18 Delegated ‘who’ the work is. Distributed‘where’the work is
09:25:07                 Durational: keep repeating the processes.
09:25:37                   constrained range of shapes
09:25:55                     Providing the opportunity for people to encounter  (and potentially re-encounter) the art as it evolves
09:26:19  where does agency sit between lead artist,artist participants?
09:26:30                    Strict rules of mark making by lead artist - and how that slips and moves between delegates
09:27:06                  arbitrary as against method
09:27:13                    Trust as technique perhaps
09:27:16          guide towards practices that are ‘good enough’
09:28:56                    Close reading as a creative act
09:29:11                 YES to a close reading as a creative act.
09:29:26 working within constraints/conventions of language & research
09:31:28                   This really struck me in the reading: "At times, in retrospect, the process developed might seem like a method. But repeating it will never bring it back, for techniques must be reinvented at every turn and thought must always leap." Erin Manning
09:32:18                     Quantum aesthetics…
09:33:08                I really appreciate your knowledge on this Vahri. It’s great to listen to you frame and position your work.
09:33:37                 Like the ‘good enough’ approach
09:35:12                    practice as unending
09:36:05           the tension between rules and experimentation…
09:36:07we are always in contradiction with/at odds with something
09:37:11        That intersection between experiment and public perception / rigour / outcomes is really interesting/challenging
09:37:15                    limitations as exciting part
09:37:27                  the tensions are where it all happens
09:38:26                   rules = “invisible map”
09:39:27           delegates experienced training in technique in order to be responsive and break rules
09:41:39                  social cultural context of individual identity politics/representation
09:43:20                   https://www.facebook.com/VahriMcKenzie/
09:48:12            these are some examples of feminist practices and what they DO, make happen and make possible
09:49:49                 Interruptions is also a feminist practice
09:51:46             Processes and techniques…part of a tradition
09:51:54                 commitment to sharing...
09:51:59                      I wonder if the paints are washed away after each visitor or if there are any 'traces'...
09:52:11                    Labour relations
09:53:12                 What and how does a project INVITE
09:53:31   the 'work' is the process not just the deliverable on the wall speaks to a feminist approach to the idea of work
09:54:05  Distributing…co-authorship…interpretations…generative…
09:54:23                  sharing is women's work
09:55:01                    personal as a political distribution
09:55:10                  listening in real time
09:55:15     story-telling and story-listening... emotion + words
09:55:36                 Situated knowledges
09:55:50             Turning up the colour of lived experiences
09:55:53                 Making it public
09:56:08                      Talking with instead of talking  at
09:57:05                  are the chosen shapes political?
09:57:29                  There's something there for me (in the context of teaching a unit on feminist leadership) in the method as feminist: the distribution of power (of the artist/expression), the making visible  of the constraints of agency of the artist (ideas of agency as contextual/relational)
09:58:12                the thinking is in the doing of the piece
09:58:12       The work is not the mural - the work is more-than- it lives in process, experience, intimacy, pleasure, attention
09:58:19         freedom, pleasure, intimacy in the experience.
09:58:42                      The mural is a 'visual trace' of the interactive experience between artist and participant
09:58:43                  The choice of the artist - taking the colour away from the participant. What does this say about agency?
09:59:10                    More than one way
09:59:29                 The exchange as a feminist practice.
10:00:06                  Identity as iterative, not fixed.
10:00:10                  colour is emotional
10:00:11                 A partial snapshot.
10:00:56              I loved the live practice as a springboard
10:01:08                  colour as now
10:01:24 Towards modes of mattering and patterns of relationality…
10:01:34                      Grappling with the practices and constantly exchanging the ideas is feminist practices
10:01:38                  Colouring the present
10:02:45 if the work is the process, then the people that describe the colours are workers of that work.are the workers describing colours recognized as artists of this artwork?
10:03:16  Interesting question about more-than-human participation
10:03:30                     Thanks  Vahri
10:03:36                     Thanks :)

(This entry was co-authored by The Ediths: Mindy Blaise, Jo Pollitt, and Jane Merewether. Inspired by the presentation by Dr. Vahri McKenzie at the Ediths Roundtable Series 2021)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *